Keyport Fishery

Located at 150 W Front St in Keyport, NJ, Keyport Fishery is a beloved seafood market and takeout restaurant that has been winning over locals and visitors alike with its fresh, flavorful offerings and no-nonsense approach to dining. Specializing in seafood dishes that pay homage to traditional shore favorites, this spot is your go-to destination for crave-worthy fish and chips, succulent shrimp platters, tender scallops, and expertly cleaned crabs. Whether you’re stopping by to select the freshest catch from their well-stocked fish market or grabbing a hearty takeout meal, Keyport Fishery offers an authentic taste of the Jersey Shore’s maritime bounty.

Step inside, and you’ll discover a surprisingly spacious interior that belies the modest exterior — a cozy, welcoming atmosphere perfect for a quick seafood fix. The bustling energy here on weekends speaks volumes about their popularity, so arriving early or prepared to wait a few minutes for your meal is part of the experience. Ample parking adds to the convenience, making this an easy stop during a day out in Keyport.

What truly sets Keyport Fishery apart is its unwavering commitment to quality and generous portions. Customers consistently rave about the perfectly battered and crispy fish & chips, where the golden crust gives way to flaky, tender fish within, creating an irresistible textural contrast. The shrimp platter is another standout, boasting a light, crunchy batter paired with fries that arrive hot and satisfyingly crisp. The scallops, praised for their excellent flavor and juiciness, showcase the kitchen’s skill, even if some dishes can occasionally vary – like the flounder which, while flavorful, can sometimes come out a touch dry.

Real customer experiences highlight the friendly, skilled staff, with Miguel’s attention to detail when cleaning crabs being a memorable touch that shows how much care goes into every order. Reviewers appreciate the consistency and freshness of the seafood, underscoring the value found here compared to other places that often disappoint. While the restaurant only accepts cash, it’s evident that the quality, portion size, and authentic taste more than compensate for this minor inconvenience.

All in all, Keyport Fishery offers much more than just seafood — it’s a genuine local treasure that captures the spirit of New Jersey’s shore fare. From the lively vibe to the ocean-fresh menu, visiting here feels like a delicious step into a community that cherishes great food and honest service. Whether you're craving classic fried seafood or eager to shop for the freshest catch, Keyport Fishery delivers that satisfying, homemade quality that keeps guests coming back time and time again.